You choose, we deliver
If you are interested in this story, you might be interested in others from The Journal Gazette. Go to and pick the subjects you care most about. We'll deliver your customized daily news report at 3 a.m. Fort Wayne time, right to your email.

Editorial columns

  • Public school backers deserve your backing
    Elections in Indiana are critically important and represent the most fundamental decision-making authority of a representative government. Elections choose our leadership and guide our state’s future.
  • $2 billion surplus is goal, no matter the cost
    Shortly after the close of the fiscal year last June 30, our governor and auditor glowingly reported that our state had a budget surplus of more than $2 billion. How were we able to achieve this?
  • Literacy an investment with lifelong benefits
    September is Literacy Month, a chance to raise awareness about low adult literacy.

Visionary Coats takes lead to lower debt

Replace sequester with bipartisan, negotiated budget cuts

In Indiana, we are proud of Sen. Dan Coats’ willingness to work across the aisle to solve problems. He has tirelessly promoted the interests of Hoosier farmers, families and small businesses, and he has helped Indiana develop a diverse and healthy economy.

But in the face of the current political schism, can Coats work on a bipartisan compromise to fix the debt?

Some commentators suggest that Congress has done enough already, citing short-term deficit reduction. To be sure, Congress has made considerable progress on deficit reduction the past three years, but lawmakers still haven’t done anything to confront the long-term drivers of our debt.

In his testimony before the Budget Conference Committee, Congressional Budget Office Director Doug Elmendorf made the argument that long-term burdens will cause the debt trajectory to increase.

“Under CBO’s extended current-law baseline, federal debt held by the public, which is already quite high by historical standards, is projected to reach 100 percent of GDP 25 years from now, even without accounting for the harmful economic effects of rising debt,” Elmendorf said.

Those debt levels are unsustainable – interest payments are projected to reach $1 trillion by 2023, squeezing out future investments. Therefore, it is time for a comprehensive plan for dealing with the long-term trajectory of debt relative to the economy.

To start, lawmakers must replace some of the deep, indiscriminate sequester cuts. The across-the-board cuts to priorities such as education, research and small business loan guarantees have hurt the economy in Indiana amid a fragile economic recovery.

Coats understands the importance of replacing sequestration. In April, he called on President Barack Obama to jump start a bipartisan budget process that would replace some of the cuts with smarter reforms. Obama did not heed the senator’s call, but the Budget Conference Committee has a real chance now to negotiate a credible sequester replacement. Coats should encourage the conferees to reach an agreement before the committee dissolves on Dec. 13.

But replacing sequestration alone won’t be enough. Congress should reduce or eliminate some of the $1.3 trillion in wasteful tax expenditures that weaken our tax code and harm our global competitiveness.

Sens. Max Baucus and Orrin Hatch, chairman and ranking member of the Senate Finance Committee, have put forth a process for considering bipartisan reforms for simplifying our tax code. These reforms could lower tax rates across the board while helping to pay down the debt, which would be a major boon for Indiana taxpayers and businesses.

Coats has demonstrated his willingness to lead on bipartisan tax reform in the Senate. Working with Sen. Ron Wyden, Democrat from Oregon, he introduced the first major bipartisan tax reform legislation in more than 20 years, the Bipartisan Tax Fairness and Simplification Act of 2011. Indianans should urge him to support the Baucus-Hatch efforts, which could be a vehicle for the common sense reforms he proposed with Wyden.

But perhaps most urgently, Coats and his colleagues have an obligation to strengthen Social Security and Medicare and account for the fact that Americans are living longer.

Ask any of Coats’ constituents in Indiana – it is a foregone conclusion that younger generations of Americans won’t receive their Social Security or Medicare benefits. But if we implement real reforms, like asking wealthy seniors to pay more, assessing inflation more accurately or streamlining Medicare delivery, we can improve quality of care and help rein in skyrocketing costs.

A portion of the savings could then be used to protect low-income seniors and vulnerable populations. If designed correctly, these changes could strengthen our entitlement programs to protect them for future generations.

Given the unsustainable trajectory of the national debt relative to the economy, Coats knows that we need a bipartisan compromise. Indiana elected officials have a long history of doing what it takes to solve our most difficult problems.

All Hoosiers should come together to encourage Coats to work across the aisle and help negotiate a comprehensive deficit reduction framework.

John Mutz, former Indiana lieutenant governor, is a member of the Indiana Chapter of the Campaign to Fix the Debt. He wrote this for The Journal Gazette.