You choose, we deliver
If you are interested in this story, you might be interested in others from The Journal Gazette. Go to www.journalgazette.net/newsletter and pick the subjects you care most about. We'll deliver your customized daily news report at 3 a.m. Fort Wayne time, right to your email.

Editorial columns

  • Exchange students learn Hoosier ways
    Throughout this month, 40 AFS international high school students from 21 countries are scheduled to arrive in Indiana.
  • Use common sense in Common Core debate
    The national debate over Common Core State Standards has intensified in recent months as several states have begun rejecting the standards in favor of drafting their own. My home state, Indiana, was the first to choose this path.
  • New censorship study reveals what Beijing fears
    While living for more than a decade in China, and using its thriving social media, no question came to mind quite so often as: “Who is the idiot who just censored that online post, and what on Earth was so dangerous about it?
Advertisement

A tragic reminder of oil’s cost

The tragic loss of lives in a Canadian border town to a fireball of burning crude oil is sure to ramp up debate about how petroleum products should be moved.

One sure talking point is that oil is moved more safely by pipeline than rail – a lynchpin for proponents of the Keystone XL pipeline. But Saturday’s accident should renew focus on just how safe those long black oil tankers are in a crash.

Pipeline spills resulted in average releases of more than 19,000 gallons per incident between 2005 and 2009. Tank cars averaged just less than 1,700.

Since October 2011, the Association of American Railroads has required tanker makers to make new cars with heavier steel, protective shields and better covers over fittings.

But the industry has rejected as too costly calls to retrofit tens of thousands of older tankers.

Crude oil isn’t going to stop riding the rails to refineries. Although pipelines still move the bulk of crude oil, trains are carrying 10 times more than they were just five years ago.

Oil producers, railroads and refiners are all hurrying to add terminals and expand tanker fleets to catch all the crude oil running out of the Great Plains. Some analysts speculate that even if Keystone is never approved, rail eventually will be able to carry all the shale and tar sands crude the region can produce.

If that’s the case, people living along the lines can only hope the tankers running through their towns meet the highest standards.

Advertisement