Wednesday, June 19, 2013 5:09 pm
Italian icons find no respite from tax man
By COLLEEN BARRYAssociated Press
Some of Italy's most well-heeled residents have come under the glare of successive governments who have declared wars on tax evasion, yet it remains a perennial problem for the debt-laden nation. On Wednesday, it was the turn of designers Domenico Dolce and Stefano Gabbana, who were convicted of failing to declare 200 million euros ($268 million).
Former Premier Silvio Berlusconi declared a tax amnesty in 2009, repatriating billions at a negligible penalty of 5 percent. He, too, has been caught up in the crackdown: Last year the billionaire media mogul was convicted of tax fraud related to his media business, a charge he denies.
His successor, Premier Mario Monti, dispatched tax police to resorts to ensure that receipts were being properly issued and income declared. While hiding income abroad may suit the jet-set, a more widely practiced and insidious form of evasion in Italy is the failure to issue receipts for anything from handy work to private medical visits to a cup of espresso.
By some estimates, as much as 20 percent of Italy's GDP is lost to tax evasion - a sum that if recouped would help Italy pay down its 2 trillion euro debt.
Here's a look at some of the biggest names in the dragnet:
A Milan court on Wednesday convicted Dolce and Gabbana of tax evasion for failing to declare 200 million euros ($268 million) through a Luxembourg company to Italian authorities. They received a one year and eight months suspended jail sentence and ordered to pay a penalty of 500,000 euros (about $670,000) to tax authorities.
The court, however, acquitted them of misrepresenting income of 416 million euros (around $560 million) each, ruling that no crime had been committed.
The designers have denied the charges, and the defense has pledged to appeal the ruling.
Berlusconi was convicted last fall of tax fraud in the purchase of rights to broadcast U.S. movies on his private TV network. An appeals court in May upheld the conviction, four-year jail term and five year ban on public office.
Berlusconi has contested the convictions, and called the judicial reasoning for the appeal `'surreal."
The appellate court said there was `'conclusive evidence, oral and documented, that Berlusconi directly managed ... an enormous tax evasion through off-shore companies."
Berlusconi's defense is planning to appeal to the country's highest court.
They lost a separate challenge at the constitutional court level Wednesday that could have caused the trial and appellate court sentences to collapse. That court rejected a defense argument that the trial court judge had improperly gone ahead with scheduled testimony on a day then-Premier Berlusconi had a Cabinet meeting in Rome. It noted he had previously indicated to the trial court his availability.
Soccer star Diego Maradona sold a diamond earring to help pay off his 37 million euro tax bill to Italy. Valued at 5,500 euros, it netted 25,000 euros at a 2010 auction.
Maradona's Italian debts stem from unpaid taxes during the time he played for Napoli from 1984-91.
The Equitalia tax collection agency said the auction take was a drop in the bucket - but sent a message that even celebrities had to pay taxes.
Seven-time motorcycling world champion Valentino Rossi was snagged by tax authorities who monitored his comings and goings to Italy. He had declared his tax home in London, but ran afoul of the tax man when his presence in Italy exceeded the foreign resident test.
Rossi, then Italy's highest paid athlete, paid about 19 million euros in 2008 to settle the dispute with tax authorities, who accused him of not declaring earnings of 60 million euros from 2000-2004.
After reaching the settlement, Rossi said he had decided to live in Italy again.
"London is a very interesting city, but spending more time with my family and my friends has become of greater importance considering all my affairs around the world," Rossi said.
Luciano Pavarotti wore a pinstripe suit over black sneakers for his reckoning with the Italian tax man.
The tenor showed up in person at the Finance Ministry in 2000 to seal an agreement to pay nearly 25 billion lire (around $12 million) to the Italian state after unsuccessfully claiming that the tax haven of Monte Carlo, rather than Italy, was his official residence.
"I cannot live being thought not a good person," Pavarotti told reporters at the time.
Pavarotti, who died in 2007, always denied wrongdoing, and insisted he paid taxes where ever he performed.
"It's very difficult to explain the life of one who travels the world, and who every year visits 50 different cities," he said at the time.
Oscar-winning actress Sophia Loren spent 17 days in prison in 1982 for tax evasion.
An Italian court convicted Loren in 1980 of filing an incorrect tax return for 1970, understating her earnings by 5 million lire, then worth about $7,000. Loren at the time was residing abroad.
Loren decided later to return to Italy to serve the sentence, and was arrested upon landing at Rome's Leonardo da Vinci airport from Geneva. Fans and fellow inmates at the prison north of Naples cheered Loren as guards ushered into a small pink cell. The 47-year-old movie star wore a green silk dress and tinted glasses.