Jason Collins has been compared with Jackie Robinson. And Neil Armstrong.
True pioneer? Not exactly.
Now that weve had a few days to reflect on what it means for Collins to come out as gay, its time to recognize what this really was – a significant step, to be sure, but hardly a slam-dunk leap toward an equal playing field.
To be clear, Im pulling hard for Collins to be on an NBA roster next season, to get a chance to show all the doubters and nay-sayers that a gay man can be just another guy in a pro sports locker room.
But even if Collins does land another contract – hardly a sure thing, given hes a 34-year-old journeyman center who barely played this season for the woeful Washington Wizards and is now a free agent – Im not convinced this will be as groundbreaking as so many are making it out to be.
For starters, anyone who plays with Collins will have a whole summer to prepare for the inevitable, annoying questions, to bury their beliefs or prejudices so deep theres no chance of getting them to reveal how they really feel. Theyll know that Collins likely will be around for one more year, so they can keep smiling and saying how proud they are to have him as a teammate. Very soon, hell be gone.
Even if another team gives Collins a chance to play, he isnt going to be on the court much. A 7-footer with limited offensive skills, hes logged an average of 34 games over the last five seasons. Those rare spots he did get in, he averaged fewer than 11 minutes of playing time.
At best, maybe theres a handful of games, most likely when his team faces one of the leagues few imposing centers, like Dwight Howard and Roy Hibbert.
At worst, he comes off as a token, a player whose career would have been over had he not come out, who gets a job because the league or a team wants to look progressive.
As former Dolphins linebacker Channing Crowder said on his radio show in Miami, Collins revelation isnt going to have the same effect as a younger player who is either a starter or at least a significant contributor, whose best years are ahead.
Him being the low-end player he is, its not going to open enough minds, said Crowder, who also said he respects Collins for taking such a bold step.
Others went way, way overboard in the heat of the moment.
Boston Celtics coach Doc Rivers made comparisons with Robinson, who became the first black major leaguer in 1947. TV pundit Star Jones referenced Rosa Parks, who sparked the Montgomery bus boycott of the 1950s, a landmark event in the civil rights movement. Olympic gold medalist Greg Louganis, who came out after his diving career ended, looked to the heavens for the appropriate analogy.
It is almost like Neil Armstrong on the moon, Louganis said. One small step for man, one giant step for mankind.
While the praise for Collins was generally universal, a sign of how much the country has moved in the right direction on issues of sexuality, there are still plenty of reasons to be skeptical of just how much the macho world of pro sports will be accepting of a gay teammate.
Despite the efforts of athletes like NFL players Chris Kluwe (waived Monday by the Vikings) and Brendon Ayanbadejo, who have spoken passionately in support of gay marriage, the guess is more players feel like San Francisco 49ers cornerback Chris Culliver and Miami Dolphins receiver Mike Wallace.
Culliver stirred debate before the Super Bowl when he proclaimed that none of his teammates was gay and he wouldnt want to play with a homosexual. Wallace tweeted after the Collins announcement that he didnt understand how someone could be gay – All these beautiful women in the world and guys wanna mess with other guys SMH (shaking my head).
Wallace had to backtrack from, delete and eventually apologize for two tweets; Culliver also apologized and underwent sensitivity training. Nevertheless, Ayanbadejo estimates that at least half the NFL players feel the same way.
I got an idea of how a locker room works a few years ago while working on a story about this very subject: whether pro sports was ready to accept an active player coming out as gay. Now-retired pitcher John Smoltz made it clear he was opposed to homosexuality on religious grounds, even asking derisively, Whats next? Marrying an animal?
All of these point to what Collins or any gay athlete must overcome.
The machismo. The lack of understanding. The religious beliefs. The wariness of being in an intimate setting.
More likely, Collins will be remembered as the guy whose courage helped persuade someone with more impact to come out.
Our sexuality does not define us, Louganis said. It is just a part of us, like being left-handed or 5-foot-9.
Were getting closer, but Collins isnt the guy to get us there.
Hopefully, the next person will be.